News

Industrial AI: Why Industrial AI Doesn’t Scale and Fails. The problem isn’t the data; it’s the lack of management commitment.

Everyone is talking about industrial AI. Predictive maintenance, quality analytics, closed-loop production, digital data products. Investments are rising, pilot projects are multiplying, and yet the question that comes up in every honest management meeting remains the same: Why isn’t this scaling for us?

The common answer is: poor data quality. This diagnosis is so well-established that it is rarely questioned. In our experience, however, it falls short in most cases. Poor data quality is often a real problem—but it is not automatically the root cause. Our thesis: When it comes to scaling Industrial AI in manufacturing organizations, there is often a lack of management commitment and an organizational operating system that makes data quality mandatory.

Top Consultant Award

Expert

Tim Naumann

Senior Manager

Satisfied customers from SMEs and large corporations

Executive Summary – Industrial AI: The Data Quality Myth

The Inconvenient Truth About Industrial AI: Why Industrial AI Fails: The Convenient Explanation of “Data Quality” Is Wrong

When industrial AI initiatives run into trouble, the same culprit is almost always identified: data quality. This diagnosis has a reassuring quality. It sounds technical, is difficult to refute, and shifts responsibility to an area that remains comfortably abstract for decision-makers.

The problem: In most cases, it’s not true. Poor data quality is a real challenge, but it’s often not the actual cause. Rather, it’s the organizationally accepted explanation for a business case that was economically unsound from the start.

Imagine if a smartphone manufacturer were to say, after a failed product launch: “The display wasn’t good enough; the business case failed.” No one would accept that. Instead, they would recalculate the business case, switch suppliers, mobilize engineering resources, and solve the problem. When it comes to data, however, we accept exactly this kind of explanation, move on to the next proof of concept, and hope that the next tool will provide the solution.

As long as this diagnosis is not honestly made, the pattern will repeat itself.

Your Experts in Industrial AI

Tim Naumann

Senior Manager

Ansprechpartner
Anne Berners

Consultant

Why Data Is Not a Product: The Missing Industrial Operating System for Data

The real question isn’t: How do we improve data quality? The real question is: Why don’t we structurally treat data as products in industrial contexts, even though this concept has been known for years?

The answer is uncomfortable. Over the course of about 150 years of industrialization, manufacturing has developed a highly sophisticated operating system for distributed value creation. This operating system does not exist in the realm of data. Six dimensions highlight the structural difference.

  • In manufacturing, there are tolerances, standards, and binding technical drawings. In the IT department, people often say, “The schema is somewhere in Confluence, I think.”
  • In manufacturing, there are inspection plans, incoming goods inspections, and statistical process control. When it comes to data, checks are usually performed on a sample basis and after the fact—often only when a model or analytics case fails.
  • In manufacturing, there are complaints, penalties, and supplier audits. When it comes to data, there are no consequences for a supplier that provides poor-quality data.
  • Profession and Identity. In manufacturing, there are quality engineers, foremen, and operators who take pride in their work and have clear career paths. The role of the data steward lacks a comparable professional ethos. Data remains a byproduct of the actual work.
  • The Cost of Poor Quality. In manufacturing, quality costs are visible, can be allocated to specific cost centers, and are measurable in the income statement. When it comes to data, these costs are diffuse, aggregated, and not noticeable to individuals.
  • In manufacturing, there are Andon systems, stop rights, Poka Yoke, and Kaizen. In the world of data, there is no systematic feedback from the data consumer to the data producer.

The structural implication is clear. In manufacturing organizations, data is generated as a byproduct of physical processes. The purpose of a PLC, an MES, or a worker is not data production, but physical value creation. As long as that remains the case, one can define a thousand data products and promote Data Mesh at conferences. Without extending the manufacturing operating system to data, nothing will fundamentally change. Standards such as ISA-95 / IEC 62264 provide the necessary specification language for this, but they do not replace a model of responsibility and operation.

Why Cultural Change Doesn't Work: Industrial AI Needs Incentives, Not Insight

At this point, calls for cultural change are regularly heard. From our perspective, this is the weakest aspect of the usual debate. Cultural change does not arise from insight. It arises from changed incentives and concrete consequences.

Data Mesh, Data Products, Data Contracts, Federated Governance. These concepts have been a staple at every conference for five years or more, featured in every consulting presentation, and described in countless white papers. And yet, they are still not being effectively implemented in most manufacturing organizations. Not because the concepts are wrong, but because they’re being applied in the wrong place.

Organizational behavior changes when four conditions are met simultaneously: Data quality is a component of the responsible manager’s personal bonus agreement; data errors result in real, attributable costs for the responsible unit. There is a clearly defined role with a career path and a professional code of ethics. And data consumers provide direct, immediate feedback to the data producers.

Everything else is just rhetorical talk about methods with no practical impact. Data industrialization does not arise from insight; it arises from economic necessity. The crucial question, therefore, is: Who creates this necessity, and when?

Forcing Functions: Where the Momentum for Industrial AI Really Comes From

This is the crux of the matter. In practice, we can distinguish between two fundamentally different types of industrial AI business cases, which give rise to very different organizational dynamics.

Optimization cases include predictive maintenance, quality analytics, and energy optimization. These cases have a local impact, are not business-critical, and can generally be circumvented. They can be implemented to some extent using workaround data. They do not create any real organizational pressure and thus do not drive the industrialization of data. They make up the majority of today’s industrial AI activities. And structurally, they are insufficient.

Forcing functions are business cases in which poor data quality does not simply mean that AI does not work as well, but rather that a compliance violation occurs, production comes to a halt, a customer promise is broken, or a multi-site strategy fails. These cases demand commitment because inaction leads to concrete, severe consequences.

There are four common types of forcing functions found in manufacturing organizations:

  • Digital Product Passport, CBAM, CSRD, pharmaceutical serialization, EU Data Act. These requirements demand a level of data quality that cannot be achieved without true industrialization. Compliance is a top-management issue, not just a “nice-to-have.”
  • Closed-loop applications. Data directly controls production: advanced process control, inline quality control, automated scheduling. Poor data quality in these applications results in immediately visible damage, production downtime, scrap, and safety risks.
  • Delivery time commitments, quality certifications, CO₂ footprint per unit as a selling point, data-driven services. When data becomes part of the product being sold, it creates the kind of market pressure that’s the toughest to handle.
  • M&A and multi-site consolidation. Plant acquisitions, relocations, standardization programs. These events have clear timeframes, require significant attention from executive management, and necessitate the comparability of data across locations.

The strategic crux of the matter: Most industrial AI strategies do not fail because of technology or data. They fail because they attempt to use optimization cases to finance data industrialization, which can only be financed through forcing-function cases. The question is not how many use cases you have. The question is whether even one of them is compelling enough to compel your organization to pursue industrialization.

From PoC to Industrial MVP: Why Industrial AI Must Move Beyond the Proof of Concept

If forcing functions are the source of this dynamic, this has an uncomfortable implication for the way industrial AI initiatives are launched. Those who use proofs of concept as a substitute for commitment are simply postponing the actual decision.

That said, there are legitimate PoCs—namely, when there is genuine technological uncertainty: new sensor technology, unclear model robustness, or unresolved questions regarding stakeholder acceptance. In such cases, a PoC is a useful tool, provided it is strictly time-limited and accompanied by clear criteria for termination and continuation.

The problem with the PoC is that it serves as a substitute for commitment. In many organizations, it is not a means of gaining insight but rather a way to avoid making decisions. It allows for activity without any obligation. It allows data quality issues to be overlooked by using workaround data. And it allows one to claim success in the event of success and to claim to have learned from failure in the event of failure, without ever having to make a real investment decision. This is precisely what prevents data industrialization.

The right replacement is the Industrial MVP. It differs from the classic PoC in six ways:

  • At least one productive user with a real-world use case—not a lab setup. A calculated business case that assigns value to the data sources and accounts for data quality costs. A real, productive data pipeline without manual extract-transform workarounds. Defined service levels already at the MVP stage, with accountability from day one. Built-in extension interfaces for future scaling. And a predefined scaling path with clear next locations, lines, and expansion phases.
  • The Industrial MVP also follows two methodological disciplines, without which it degenerates into a mere proof of concept. First: Every MVP delivers not only operational value but also structural value in the form of explicit industrialization of the underlying data sources. It must not sidestep data quality issues locally but must address them at the source. Second: The “forcing function” goal is non-negotiable. Iterations focus exclusively on the path to that goal, not the goal itself.

The Organizational Prerequisites: Why Methodology Alone Cannot Save Industrial AI

Identify forcing functions, launch the Industrial MVP, and then scale up. That’s the logic, at least. But: Both of these steps will only work if two organizational prerequisites are met—prerequisites that are structurally absent in most industrial companies.

A Data Governance Office that operates as a sub-function within IT cannot fulfill its necessary role. It is perceived as a service function and lacks both the technical clout and the political mandate to resolve conflicts between plants, corporate functions, and analytics functions.

What is needed is a governance office with three key characteristics. It should be closely aligned with the product, ideally within the CTO or CDO organization and with a mandate from the executive board. It should be deeply embedded in operations, serving as an integrated support function for the MVP streams—not as a steering committee. And it should have a strong mandate with genuine escalation authority at the decision-making level.

Essentially, this office fulfills the role that the process engineer plays in manufacturing: acting as a liaison between local plant optimization and group-wide standardization. In the world of data, this role is structurally absent. Specifically, this means translating local MVP results into the overall standard, integrating semantics, and escalating conflicts.

It is not practical to budget in advance for forcing-function projects. The timing (deadline) and scope (minimum requirements) are fixed, so the cost dimension must remain flexible. This is a concern for the CFO: Traditional investment committees do not handle this well.

The honest answer is: Traditional forward budgets in complex programs offer only a false sense of security anyway. They are regularly exceeded, masked by scope adjustments, and attributed to unforeseen complexity in post-mortems.

The iterative approach replaces this pseudo-certainty with genuine transparency: a budget range instead of a fixed amount, a defined reserve, clear escalation thresholds, and demonstrable value added per iteration. This is culturally uncomfortable, but it is actually manageable. It creates transparency and manageability, but not calculable certainty in advance. The decisive factor is what level of uncertainty the organization is willing to tolerate.

Without these two prerequisites, “Forcing Functions” and “Industrial MVP” remain merely methodological concepts on slides. With them, they become a viable operational framework for the industrialization of data.

Data Quality Expectation Ramp-Up Workshop: A Structured Introduction to Industrial AI: Data Quality Expectation Ramp-Up

Anyone who seriously wants to scale Industrial AI doesn’t need another PoC. They need clarity on which use cases are challenging enough to drive genuine commitment—and what data quality requirements actually stem from them. That’s exactly why we developed the Data Quality Expectation Ramp-Up format. It’s not a standard workshop, nor is it a dry run of a methodology. It combines two elements.

Conceptual Deep Dive. Together, we determine how data quality should actually be defined in your industrial context, beyond generic dimensions such as completeness or accuracy. Data quality is always a function of its use case. Without this contextualization, any initiative remains arbitrary. Use-Case-Driven Impact Analysis. Using your real-world use cases as a basis, we identify which data quality requirements actually arise from each case and how significant the impact on technology, processes, and the organization is likely to be. Some cases require full-scale industrialization. Others can get by with less. This distinction is often the decisive step.

That is why we combine generative AI with:

Three Honest Questions Before the Next PoC: Before You Invest in Industrial AI: Three Questions Worth Asking

The “data quality” excuse won’t go away on its own. It will persist as long as we accept it as a convenient explanation. The alternative is more challenging. But it is the only one that leads to true data industrialization.

Before you invest in the next AI pilot program, it’s worth asking yourself three honest questions:

  • Which of your current industrial AI use cases is challenging enough to drive the industrialization of your data?
  • Where do you currently treat poor data quality as an excuse rather than a specification issue?
  • Do you have the organizational resources to make a genuine commitment?

Here's What Industrial AI Can Do for You with Ventum Consulting


: Over 1,500 Projects Completed

Large corporations and small and medium-sized businesses rely on our experience because we deliver what we promise.

Focus on Business Value

We prioritize use cases based on their impact, feasibility, and measurable benefits.

100% for your
Business Success

Your measurable results are the benchmark for our work.

Strategy through
Implementation

From the initial idea to a working solution—all from a single source.

+1,500 projects
completed

Business Value
In Focus

100% for your
Business Success

Strategy through
Implementation

Conclusion on Industrial AI: The Data Quality Myth

Poor data quality is usually not the cause of failed AI initiatives, but rather the excuse for weak business cases. Data is not treated like a product in manufacturing organizations because they lack an industrial operating system. The mindset shift does not arise from insight, but from changed incentives. The momentum for this comes from forcing functions—not from optimization cases. The right tool for implementation is the Industrial MVP, not the PoC. And both work only with a product-oriented governance office and an iterative funding architecture.

Industrial AI:
Schedule a no-obligation initial consultation at now

TISAX and ISO certification apply only to the Munich location

Your message



    *Pflichtfeld

    Bitte beweise, dass du kein Spambot bist und wähle das Symbol LKW.

    FAQ – Frequently Asked Questions About Industrial AI

    Industrial AI refers to the structured, scalable use of artificial intelligence in industrial environments such as manufacturing, production, the supply chain, and engineering. Unlike general AI applications, Industrial AI operates on operational technology, sensor, and machine data and must be integrated into physical production processes. This places special demands on data quality, real-time capability, system integration, security, and governance—requirements that traditional IT-based AI approaches do not readily meet.

    In most cases, this is not due to poor technology or data, but rather to a lack of management commitment, weak business cases, and the use of proofs of concept (PoCs) as a substitute for commitment rather than as a genuine means of gaining insights. Data is not treated like a product in manufacturing organizations because the industrial operating system required for this is lacking.

    An optimization case such as predictive maintenance is effective at the local level but can be circumvented. It does not create any real organizational pressure. A forcing function—such as regulatory requirements or a closed-loop production process—has severe consequences if not implemented. Only forcing functions can compel the commitment required for data industrialization.

    An Industrial MVP has at least one active user with a real-world use case, a real, production-ready data pipeline without workarounds, a calculated business case, defined service levels from day one, and a predefined scaling path. A PoC used as a substitute for a commitment allows for activity without any binding obligations and postpones real decisions to the future.

    Scroll to Top